Registered members earn £0.50 in loyalty points for every published product review!
By NickyDrinks
If you want the actual *original* Milkman liquid you will be sorely disappointed because this is a recipe that bares very little relation to it. They don't even seem to have really even put a lot of effort into getting it right either, probably because they know they can probably sell it on the name alone with customers assuming they have bad nicotine or haven't steeped it enough. Like Mother's Milk this was one of the old massively popular liquids that were only as good as they were and had a high quality "brand" base taste type, usually made completely using flavourings containing diacetyl and other things that are no longer allowed to be sold as commercial vape liquid. The actual base flavour manufacturers have tried and done impressive work but their lack of big breakthroughs except on specific flavours (and still never as good imo) suggests that it simply cannot be recreated without them, if it could they'd have managed it years ago I suspect. Sadly it seems that this is another once excellent liquid that is now borderline tasteless thanks to America's crazy new vaping regulations and liquid manufacturers facing an impossible task while also waiting to be shut down by more ludicrous and clearly malicious regulation. There's a few amazing DIY recipes available, people who are very good at mixing have put so much work into recreating the real Milkman flavour but it was such an unusual taste that getting it exactly right may never happen, some of the flavours could be anything as they all interact in weird ways but they are till close enough to be worth looking into making as it's as close as we'll likely ever see again. Just don't mistake the other "Milkman" made by One Hit Wonder Milkman for this, that's just a generic strawberry milk with insane amounts of sweetener added, the Milkman that came in the little cardboard boxes and nice bottles was made by Vaping Rabbit. I believe the original owners make very different liquid now with very different branding which probably tells you all you need to know, I can't help but feel that the word Original being added to the name as been done for several very specific reasons but for more morally dubious ones as it first seems, they know that the ingredients of the "proper" one cannot be made into or sold as a commercial liquid but they want you to assume it's because they have so many on offer that they're trying to make it less confusing when it's actually aimed at making old customers buy something that isn't what it seems (to be fair I'm sure they'd sell gallons of the stuff if they were allowed) Unless some lucky person is holding onto masses of older stock and really likes vaping it probably no longer exists except as a reference mixture in a lab or as an entry in a register of someone's trade secrets. The Milkman does still have some good liquids despite all that weirdness, their Vanilla Custard is a surprisingly decent one for a company that doesn't just make hundreds of varities until they find one people buy more than once (e.g. The Doughnut King, Chef's Flavours original concentrate of the same name was *very* good but isn't too hard to recreate, the change was so blatant that I don't know why they weren't just honest with people) and their blueberry and chocolate ones are still worth trying but the absolute best, genuine classic original liquid that you would see on the counter of every pop-up vape shop that appeared around your own house seems like it may be gone for good unless someone stumbles across some odd extra ingredient that adds that missing taste/mouth feel. The fact that they sell this as being the original liquid just seems a bit wrong to me, unless by "Original" they mean some random recipe they tried before someone stumbled over the big one (which I would bet money is how it happened, it was so unusual and would change sometimes that doing that by design just seems to me very unlikely, not even Suicide Bunny ever managed that unless you count the "special editon" version that was almost certainly a lost container of the stuff that had been steeping so long it might as well have been pure VG). People say they used to use their own super vanilla extracting super powers and magic etc, which might be true, but if it ever was it's long gone from there. Stick some nic in VG and you have a bottle of this junk.
By Rafa from Dartford UK
I remember back in 2015 when I started vaping, This had became my most favourite e-liquid. It used to have a rich creamy milky flavour which made me fall in love with this brand. I always had this stocked before I stopped vaping in 2016/17. Four years later when I re-started vaping, this was the first flavour I bought. And I am hugely disappointed. The current flavour does not even get closer to what I once used to. It lacks classic creamy and milky flavour. I barely felt any presence of those while vaping. Maybe there was a subtle taste which I was missing. Other than that in terms of clouds and juice it does a great job, The best result I've got mixing up with other flavours.
By Anonymous
Unfortunately the best thing about this juice is the packaging it comes in, not good
By Penut
I bought this awhile back as alot of these comments have said due to the hype of it.... Also before I had started vaping my mate had had a juice and I loved it and he told me it was the milkman original. So obviously I bought it but it tastes absolutely nothing like it at all .... I couldn't really put my finger on the taste but it wasn't milky or milky clouds, just a miss match of flavours. It had a weird taste and another friend of mine really hated the smell when ever I vaped it. I have vaped acouple of milkman's since and to be honest I can't really get down with any of them. I wanted to really but I just don't like them
By Rosieoc04
Tried this about a year ago and never vape another flavour now. It’s like a pop tart with ice cream not so heavy nice flavour balance. Just the best!!!
By Kris from Isle Of Wight
Nice creamy strawberry milk. A classic flavour.
By Giggles from Somerset
At first when I bought it I had high hopes it sounded amazing.
But wasn't so I put back in the cupboard and allowed it to steep for 5 months.
After that well it was amazing, I don't like fruity vapes but this was a game changer.
Yes it needs steeping but it's lovely I get the fruit on the the inhale and vanilla bean on the exhale.
By LoveBot from Denmark
I have a softspot for creamy and milky liquids. And so far, this has been my favorite!
It's not as sweet as most others, but have a more roasted caramel after-taste, that i really dig!
Been vaping on both 35 and 50w, on 0,5 and 0,2 coils. Ranging from thinner, cold vapes, to warm and thick. Taste is very good no matter what in my opinion.
Very satisfied and will definately try out more flavours from this brand.
By Anonymous
This is an amazing tasting juice which produces lovely clouds. You can really taste the vanilla and the milky exhale is lovely.
Sadly, it's high VG content gives me vaper's tongue almost instantly making it hard to get through a tank of it, let alone a bottle.
Such a shame because they've got everything else so right with this one.
By JPH from Herts
As a few reviews below say , instantly out the bottle the flavour is not as milky as you'd like , it does require steeping ( I left mine for a week and shook vigorously in-between days )
After a 1-2 weeks the flavour does develop alot more creamy and milky taste , although there is a hint of citrus/tangy on the exhale.
7/10 taste
8/10 vapour production
If your not satisfied by this flavour DO TRY the others in the range as they are GREAT!
By Levakz from UK
I want to bring the attention of all the people purchasing this product. Please watch the reviews on youtube to realize that this ejuice is pure Sh*t!
After all the hype, the premium price , and the long delivery - Opened up a box with a set i've ordered -the Milkman and the Churrios. Guess which one was better? The sample that came from a different brand in the delivery. That was the only good thing + the boxes. But hey! Who on earth would want a carton box for this price. Please Ignore this ejuice as the taste is not as great; the clouds are not as big and definitely not 'milky' and the aftertaste is disgusting.
Its not awful, its just normal and definitely NOT WORTH the money!
The twelve monkeys are MUCH BETTER in comparison.
Avocado 24
By Salvo
I imagine most of the negative reviews are from people vaping this straight away. I've had 3 bottles of this now and unfortunately they all needed about 2-4 weeks before they tasted good and the harshness was gone.
Once they have been steeped however the flavour is great. Really smooth milky taste with a slight hint of strawberry, not too sweet or overpowering like alot of strawberry milk flavours i've had. Only downside is waiting for them to get to that stage.
Atlantis 0.3 70w
By Danno from Manchester
Not sure what the hype about this is found it to be really not that nice an not at all as the flavour describes it kind of like toasted caramel popcorn not a flavour I'd pick, would not buy again and would advise people to not believe the hype about this flavour.
By ALB from Scotland
I had it with the Churrios and I like this one better than One Hit Wonder's Milkman. This is really creamy, milky, sweet, what's not to like?
By Had from Manchester
I got the value pack and I tried them both out.
This one is pretty tastless. Sometimes, rarely, you get a faint, very faint, hint of vanilla. But it mostly tastes like milkpowder smells.
No wonder the packaging focuses on clouds, since the clouds are very thick and nice.
Would not buy again and would not reccomend anyone.
By Parkerboy
I filled my tank up the moment I got this stuff as I've heard nothing but good things!! BUT.. Like people have said.. There's a slight vomit taste going on although I do get a nice creamy flavoursome hit every now and again.. I'm gonna let this steep and give it another go because I think it has potential and don't wanna make any rash decisions..
By Abfab from Harrogate
This has been a favourite adv for me using a kanger sub mini on a 30w istick. Rich & very creamy. Sometimes you need just a bit more punch though so the perfect solution is to add a chaser - a drop of churrios.. Blended together is heaven.
By Gareth from Sheffield
Loved it from inhale number 1, flavour was exactly as described and great cloud production. Not sure if it doesn't work as well sub ohm as other reviewers seem to have issues with this juice but on an Aspire Nautilus it's amazing. Immediately re-ordered once the bottle was getting low. New favourite juice and lower price than other 30ml premium juices which is a bonus.
By Evoc from St. Petersburg
This Liquid is brilliant , great cloud maker, taste is unbelievable.
Vanilla ice cream and milk on the inhale and a really nice warm pastry with a very subtle hint of fruit (strawberry??) on the exhale.
The taste is not too strong, just right to enjoy it as an all day vape.
By Zim from Zimmer
It's absolutely delicious. But you'll need a dripper, I reckon the negative reviews are from tanks. drench the coil with it, very milky clouds with a little vanilla and fruit. its really great.
By Z from Uk
smells like you left powder nesquik open for 2 years, tastes like you're breathing a cloud of the dust, really dry burnt taste. [multiple claptons and rba's have been used]
harsh throat hit, 1 in 10 vapes come through creamy, really bee a battle vaping this, had it for 2 months, I was a sucker for the cool packaging.
giving 2/10 for vapeclub's service and the clever marketing by milkman, disappointing vape though, I highly highly recommend Milk by Glas - this flavour profile but done RIGHT!
By Jonny5 from Devon
At first this was hands down the worst liquid I have ever tasted. As a few others mentioned, it was harsh, tasted exactly like vomit and didn't even have decent clouds considering it's 99% VG. If I had reveiwed it then I would have given it the lowest score possible as I feel like I wasted £15 on something I would never use again.
But like all liquids, I gave it the benefit of the doubt and let it steep for nearly a week.
Tried again today and the juice has finally transformed into what other people are discribing... smooth, hint on fruit, not that sickly at all.
So it has redeemed itself... but only just.
I still don't think this is a good enough premium juice. Although the taste has improved the clouds still aren't very impressive. It has good presentation in terms of packaging but with all the choice out there these days I wouldn't spend on this again. My opinion is if you are thinking of choosing a new vape, give this one a miss in favour of something else, if you have money to burn, give it a go.
By Jim from Bourne Lincolnshire
Ok.. so I took a gamble as some mixed reviews but I'm guessing that's down to taste buds! But I reallllly like this juice! I'd put this in my top 3 liquids list! Wasn't sure about the milk side but yeah... amazing... get the fruit tart on inhale with a milky aftertaste! Very suprising!
By Kurlo from Somerset
Firstly I like my sweet and fruity vapes so thought I'd give this a go.I can't seem to get anything other than a really,really smooth cereal/pastry exhale,which is surprisingly savoury and morish.Not in the slightest overpowering or sickly.Definately one to keep on my purchase list
Nautilus 1.8 coil @16-22w
By Darth Vaper from Stotfold
Hard to understand the negative reviews however I have absolutely hated other juices that other people rave about. I guess it depends on your taste AND your setup. Loved this when I tried it in the shop I bought my first bottle from, tried it in my TFV4 tank with 0.15ohm quad coil and wasn't that impressed. Bought a Uwell crown tank, Vaping it now on their 0.5ohm dual coil and it's back to how it was when I first tried it.
It is unctious and thick and creamy and milky, ever so slightly yoghurty. Really nice. Just bought another bottle.
By Bigs from Wales Uk
If you like creamy milky vape then give it a go. Smells like off milk but tastes like what its supose to taste like. Just try it and review it yourself.
By Shauny T from Uk
Bought this juice about 2 months ago, put it in my subtank plus through an organic cotton wick at 0.4ohms on 30W. First impressions were that the presentation of the liquid was spot on. However upon vaping I got a very weak taste of how cardboard smells. If you know what I mean? No fruity flavour, no creamy taste and shit clouds considering its 99%vg. I wasn't impressed at all to be honest considering the hefty price tag. I thought I'd leave it to steep for a while and see if it improved, as I've done this with a few juices and they've got a lot better with age. After 2 months I've filled my tank with it again, and if anything it's worse. Would steer clear of this juice if you are looking for a satisfying vape. It's not good at all and won't buy again. Was going to try their churro flavour one but I don't think I'll risk it now
By Me
It needs steeping ... or putting in the fridge maybe? Tastes like pickle juice and pepper. Yuk
By Jimbo from London
Hideous! Avoid at all costs. Most def the worst vape I've tried. Tastes of vomit. Can't give a zero star but you get the gist.
By Danny Hunter from Newcastle Upon Tyne
this liquid is unbelievably tasty. the perfect balance between creamy vanilla. to be honest, I couldn't really taste the fruit tart but the quality and flavour makes up for that. id recommend this to anyone and everyone.
By Eng from Kuwait
Very nice and sweet milky vape
By Elliot
I'm impressed.
I purchased more on impulse than research and it paid off!
I'd pay £14.99 again for this.
It's far too nice! I'm really happy with this purchase.
I can taste the fruit tart, ice cream and milk.
If you've ever had warm milk over a desert this is the milk flavour I get.
Very well made! I'd highly recommend this.
By Leggett from Brighton
I read the hype and thought i'd try it. I like creamy,milky e juice. This is by far the worst e juice I have tried. Tastes nasty and nothing like creamy and milky flavour.
I tried this in several tanks and still the same taste. Avoid!!!
By Bernie from Seychelles
Honestly maybe i had too high a hopes for this juice, i was sold on the packaging which is a nifty looking thing, i ordered two bottles and they arrived in great condition. from the get go the strawberry is absolutely overpowering! you get tired after several hits too! i don't know if OHW eliquid has raised my bar for every other eliquid but this isn't something i'd purchase again,
Big cloud production though! so that is true
By Bigal1998 from Uk
Really don't get the negative reviews of this liquid. It's tastes creamy and very pleasant.if you like cream or desert flavours you should like it. I've been vaping for over 3 and a half years and I know what bad liquid is.This is very nice not bad or unpleasant in any way.
By Gaz from S
not overly fussed with this liquid, very average. nothing special, nothing to really write about. its not a bad liquid, but not a good one either. not buying again, price is way over the top for product. doesnt taste like milk, more like a musky...nothingness....
By Happy Vapor from Devon
I have seen lots of negative reviews regarding this juice but i brought anyway as it sounded appealing AND OH YEA IT IS::: so milky and creamy like malted milk could smok all day maybe its the set-up people are using they might not be getting the full flavour im using a rda 28 gauge kenthal dual build 2 twisted wires with a drill then wraped 6 times round a 3mm drill bit giveing me 4.4 will defiantly be buying more
By CM89 from Glasgow, Scotland
I'm seeing quite a few negative reviews but personally I adore this juice. I could vape it forever. It isn't packed with flavour, but to me that's part of it's intrigue and charm. Subtle hints of pastry and vanilla (not artificial like many juices, but like proper high quality vanilla ice-cream) fall over a creamy, full-fat, sweetened milk. The clouds are unreal. The packaging is original. £15 really isn't a bad price for 30ml. I would highly recommend it. Straight 10/10.
By Gingstar from Uk
If you like fancy packaging buy the milkman. If you like decent e juice stay away this tastes rank, smells rank and is overpriced.
By Rob
100% something wrong with that person who say this e juice is no good or u guys need to try the juice with 0mg nicotine because the nicotine changing the thaste completely! This Milkman is so delicius!!! Not too sweet, creamy and soooo milky! :) Amazing!!!!
By Aitchy from Scotland
I read the reviews, i listened to the Hype......i bought a bottle....I was pretty disappointed!!!!
Dont get me wrong...i wanted to like it,,enjoy it,,,even rave about it.
I dripped it, i put it in a tank or two, i cranked up the power then i dropped it down low. I even left it for weeks to steep and let it breathe too. But i just dont get the flavours. All i get is a weak cheap artificial fruit flavour. It produces clouds but not the flavour i was hoping for.
By Quikanth from Newcastle
Heard great stuff about this product so I ordered, was expensive!
I watched reviews on youtube after purchasing and reviews weren't good! To my disappointment when the product arrived it wasn't up to scratch!
It throws clouds but taste like artificial whatever its meant to be! Don't waste your money, buy 2 bottles of cosmic fog instead!
THIS IS A HYPED UP PRODUCT
By Jim Dee from Windsor
Brought this a few weeks back, opened and had a few hits and it was vile, left it alone for about a week with the odd shake up here and there, now it's not too bad.
Defo milky flavours I can taste but more like a pastry than anything else
7/10
By Udesky from St. Albans
Bought this about a month ago now and even after steeping for quite some time I just find it bland! You can pick up a biscuity taste and the slightest hint of strawberry at low wattage I find but it's so muted it's untrue!
Almost finished the bottle now and will definitely not be buying again, shame as there new churros flavour appealed to me but very much doubt I will bother now.
2 stars only cps you do get huge clouds!
By Abovetheclouds from London
let this juice steep for a WEEK and it's delicious. A very subtle moorish mellow creamy vape. Mothers milk esque, but slightly more muted and not so syrup sweet. Straight from the bottle and it's a problem. A sickening sour vile artificial milk problem. in my top five juices, and boy i've tried them all.
By NicknGem from Lincolnshire
Absolutely beautiful!!
This is an all ADV for me, I wouldn't say I taste milk, I do taste pastry with creamy tones but very Moorish and loads of vapor.
Recommended without a doubt!!
By Anonymous
Although this is a nice juice it should NOT be mistaken for one hit wonders milkman which comes in 180ml bottles for a very reasonable price
By Mdb from Aberdeen
If you like mothers milk, you're gonna be a fan of this. I'd say it was probably better!
The milkiness is the first thing I notice but after a while more of the pastry.
I tried in a 3, super smooth and nice cloud production.
Vaped through kindred 2 and royal hunter.
Going to give this my first 10.
By Sasto from Sheffield
The smell from this juice is a lovely fresh bakery type smell, unfortunately the taste just doesn't come out. Maybe it needs some steeping to get the flavours, but right out of the box it's just not hitting the mark. A little harsh on the inhale at 20W on a Kanger Subtank Mini.
By Local Legend from Cheltenham
Where's the hype come from?
This is absolutely terrible. Not even close to the flavour profile.
Smells bad,tastes bad and although the packaging is clever it's very cheap and you can't vape packaging
By Rob from London
I'm into my creamy flavours, so thought this was right up my street. But was a little let down
I agree with other reviews in that it does get better over time.
Worth buying to add to your collection for the packaging alone
By Kvapors from London
Presentation of this eliquid is out of this world. Easly one of the best bits of packaging I've ever seen.
First thing I noticed when I opened the box is that this comes in a plastic bottle. I've purchased eliquid for a third of the price and it's still come in glass bottles.
The aroma is intriguing but the flavour isn't even remotely close to what they've advertised. There's just an overpowering caramel, sour milk, something reminiscent of a bakery product and absolutely no fruit, all mushed together with no definition between flavours.
I've let it air out for 24 hours which has helped to tone down the flavour slightly but I think this might need a couple of weeks of steeping before it comes to life.
Considering how much I paid, and how much hype this gets, I'm less than impressed.
By Mr Fister
My personal favourite BUT the wife hates it. Not very helpful i know but if you like a sweet, creamy vape you can at least give it a go.
By Sadave from Selby
Me and the girlfriend love this stuff and did not steep so not sure why all have given a good review creamy and flavour awesome in sub ohm unit
By TibbyVapes from Cornwall
Overview: this is one of those vapes i could see some people able to vape a whole bottle in a day and others not able to stomach a puff, very sweet with the pastry being dominant in flavor with tones of vanillas n creams
Clouds: decent vapor production cant fault it there, thick dense clouds from a thick dense liquid
Flavor: alot have said it is too weak, personally i found it too strong for a cream, its more like a very rich dessert, enjoyable in small quantities but rapidly becomes sickly
Presentation: the box is great and i have lots of bottles and equipment on display so its wonderful even just for that
Final Verdict: its worth a try to those who are interested and can live with the fact they may not like it but its like marmite, you love it or hate it
6/10 for its style and how unique it is but loses points as its not the most shareable flavor
By Flippin Eck from London
When this first arrived I gave it a sniff and wasn't too impressed. Intriguing smell, but not amazing.
Shook it, steeped it, four weeks later and it smells alright.
Subtank mini, stock vertical coil, 0.5 ohms, 30 watts, and it's quite a tasty juice. It can be a bit harsh if you take long hot hits, but I find at 35W and with short tokes I get an almost exact replica of those milk bottle sweets. Really quite intriguing.
I'm not a massive fan of those sweets, and that's my main problem. It's amusing how similar it tastes though. That being said, I am actually really enjoying it and will happily finish the bottle, but I'm not sure I'd have it again. Maybe, but I don't know. Maybe. That's how intriguing this juice is, I guess.
I think the trick with this one is to fiddle with your device until you find the best taste.
The ironic thing is that they have gone to great lengths with the packaging, but my bottle leaks from around the threads and around the base of the rubber squeezy thing on the outside of the bottle. Heh.
By Liam from Devon
heard a lot of hype about this and every time i tried to buy it, it was out of stock so when it came in I wasn't hesitant in buying it. Thick clouds from it but as for the taste i can't even explain it it was awful can only describe it as a kid opening the box at xmas that contains the puppy he has been dreaming about only to find that its dead
By Maz from Portsmouth
When I first tried this I was not a fan it didn't really taste of anything......
I gave it a few weeks and yum.......... Worth the wait......
By Stefano from London
I've tried many many different juices, sometimes I like or love one, sometimes I don't.
Its very rare that a juice make me sick .... well, this one made me sick, I was almost throwing up.
The worst juice I've ever bought so far
By Mobi from Sheffield
I have reviewed so many e-juices but this is the first review which is a bit harsh due to the hype behind this e-liquid. I don't understand the reason what so ever and am very disappointed by some of the youtube reviewers who have helped in increasing sale of this product.
While I accept everyone has a different taste buds but in my personal view, a good tasting product always taste good to the majority and not only to the few.
On this note; to me this is so far the worst premium e-liquid I have ever tasted. This e-liquid tastes so awfully sour that it can make you sick, let alone finishing your filled tank. I have tried it on tanks, on RBA, on RDA at various settings but the conclusion was it is bad.........a very badly formulated e-liquid.
Only good thing about this e-liquid is the packaging which is only good in picture. The bottle is made of white plastic (not a glass bottle as I initially thought) which is same as of a tiny yogurt drink bottle.
My overall opinion is to avoid.
